Mike Cumings
TL;DR: This is an excellent, well-built case. The tight quarters of its small form-factor do add some challenges, but these are not uncommon. I did run into a few minor areas for improvement (detailed below), but overall I am extremely pleased with my purchase and am mentioning them only to pass on knowledge I have gleaned.
This chassis ended up being exactly what I was looking for, and as it turns out is the manifestation of a rare combination of features/traits. Among the features I was specifically looking for were, 1) high 3.5" storage density, 2) small form factor (4U was my absolute max), 3) use of a standard ATX power supply and motherboard, 4) silent operation, 5) effective cooling. I immediately replaced all fans with Noctua equivalents (without even trying the stock fans), given that I wanted a low acoustic signature. With that as context:
The amount of storage density that is present in this case is excellent, providing 16 host swappable drive bays connecting to direct attach backplanes. Each tray has screw holes for mounting either 2.5" drives or 3.5" drives. The 4x direct attach backplanes are fed with a single molex plus a SFF-8087 connector and serve a horizontal row of 4 drives at SATA3 6Gb/s speed.
The fan wall is excellent. The 120mm fans allow high airflow with less speed and therefore less noise. The fans plug into a backplane which is supplied power from a single molex connector. One thing I was pleasantly surprised by is the fact that this backplane supports 4-pin PWM control for each fan. Pins 1 and 2 are power and are fed in common by the single molex connector. Pins 3 and 4 from each fan are separately routed to a 6 pin header (2x3). I created a custom cable to attach these pins to my motherboard's connectors, giving me PWM control and monitoring of the 3 fans. This is excellent!
As the other reviewer pointed out, cable management is tough given the tight spaces involved. This comes with the small form-factor territory though. I only had two minor issues, both of which were easily resolved by temporarily removing the fan wall: 1) Running the 4x Molex connectors to the HDD backplanes was tough, given the number of cables being run through the same small hole at the side of the fan wall, given that space is also needed to insert and remove the first fan as well as supply the fan power and pin-3/4 cables. 2) The holes in the sides of the fan wall were smaller than the connectors I needed to pass through. I solved this by removing one small piece of metal at the outside edge of the hole. Given the 120mm fan dimensions and the standard server width, there is very little room for actual improvement here but I wanted to mention it.
Areas for potential improvement:
The rear of the drive cage where the backplanes mount could be improved to allow better airflow, as the backplane boards themselves form a bit of a wall. There are holes at the back of the 5.25" bays which allow a lot of airflow from the 3.5" drive bays but if the 5.25" bays are filled this may result in less airflow around the 3.5" drives. I do not yet have my chassis significantly populated, so this is only speculation.
It would be nice if the backplanes could be upgraded to SFF-8643 Mini-SAS HD connectors. This may be a problem limited to my specific scenario however, as my motherboard has 2x OcuLink connector for which there does not appear to be an OcuLink to SFF-8087 breakout cable available anywhere I searched.
The PCI slot covers are break-off only. They cannot be replaced once broken off. It would be nice to have reusable ones that would better allow for reconfiguration of the PCI slots.
Very nit-picky, but the LEDs on the front bleed a lot of light into their neighboring LEDs, making it difficult to tell which are actively illuminated and which are being illuminated by their neighbor. A bit of optical separation would help here.
A more in depth photo gallery and/or a small, downloadable user manual to demonstrate the full capabilities of the case would be an easy win.
Review Submit 19th Oct 2020
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Instagram
Call us today on 01283 576162 to talk directly to one of our server specialists
Who we are
Server Case are the UK's server case and components specialists, selling PC cases, server cases, 19" Rackmount cases, Backplane modules, mobile disk racks, externam disk boxes and power supplies. server systems and components with thousands of products available to purchase securely online.
UK's only authorised eCommerce reseller of server chassis to the general public & companies.
Latest News
Server Case UK Attains Asus Business Gold Partner Status.
Posted on: 7th Oct 2019
We are very proud to announce our appointment as an ASUS Business Gold Partner.We have successfully grown our sales of Asus server & workstation motherboards as well as server barebone and complete solutions with a variety of new customers from new markets.Our longstanding expertise in servers and rack mo... [...] Read more
Latest Blog
Intel Core Series vs AMD Ryzen
Posted on: 27th May 2020
The two major competitors in the processor market are undoubtably Intel and AMD. Server Case UK group will be comparing various Intel and AMD product ranges to the closest equivalent product range of the other manufacturer, to determine the differences between them and find what you should be using. This will... [...] Read more
Latest Video
View more of our reviews, unboxing and installation videos on YouTube.
Business Links
Site Information